
The PIER
DSE Pedagogical Insights and Educational Resources
April 1, 2019
Evidence Based Programs: Ensuring Quality Implementation
High-quality implementation (often referred to as "fidelity") means implementing classroom lessons and activities as intended by the program’s developer. This would include teaching all of the lessons in sequence, and carefully following the instructions within each lesson plan so that all of the points and objectives are covered using the methods intended by the author of the program.
High-quality implementation also has a qualitative component. Teachers are said to implement well when they are prepared, when they make desired points with clarity, teach with enthusiasm, and create a climate of respect so that students feel safe and engaged in the process. Because every group of students is unique in terms of experiences, needs and cultural background, implementing well also means knowing when and how a program may need to be adapted in order to achieve its goals. It's possible to retain fidelity to program design by making sure any modifications are aligned with the program's message and objectives.
Fidelity of a program can still be met when teachers include additional activities or incorporate higher order questioning techniques as long as they are aligned to the purpose of the lesson or activity within the instructional program. For example, during a lesson utilizing the Wilson Reading Program, asking students extended vocabulary questions that include real world connections or use of the word in context can enrich student understanding without impeding the fidelity of the program implementation. The key point to remember is that we teach children....not programs.
Answer to Digital Data Collection Question
Question: "We have several students we're tracking behavior with using either Discrete Trial Training or other means of behavior goal tracking. Teachers and support staff have worked so hard collecting this data. what recommendations do you have for digitizing this data for students who could really use an electronic paper trail?”
Peer Answer:
There have been some conversation about confidentiality, but our team, in the past has collected data with a shared folder within the drive. We used initials to identify the student but everyone who worked with the child within the week or every day had access to the folder and added data specific to the child’s behavior plan. The case manager would review the data and be responsible for reports and interpretation.This works for academic intervention data as well.